Pseudoscience : The Conspiracy Against Science /
"In a post-truth, fake news world, we are particularly susceptible to the claims of pseudoscience. When emotions and opinions are more widely disseminated than scientific findings, and self-proclaimed experts get their expertise from Google, how can the average person distinguish real science f...
Otros Autores: | , |
---|---|
Formato: | Electrónico eBook |
Idioma: | Inglés |
Publicado: |
Cambridge, Massachusetts :
The MIT Press,
[2018]
|
Colección: | Book collections on Project MUSE.
|
Temas: | |
Acceso en línea: | Texto completo |
Tabla de Contenidos:
- Intro
- Contents
- Foreword: Navigating a Post-Truth World: Ten Enduring Lessons from the Study of Pseudoscience
- Acknowledgments
- Introduction: Pseudoscience: What It Costs and Efforts to Fight It
- I. The Basics of Pseudoscience
- 1. Pseudoscience and the Pursuit of Truth
- Doubting Science
- The Demarcation Fallacy
- Boundary Work
- The Pseudoscientific Threat
- References
- 2. The Psychology of (Pseudo)Science: Cognitive, Social, and Cultural Factors
- The Psychology of Science
- What Is Scientific Thinking?
- Individual Factors: Cognition and Metacognition
- Social Factors
- Cultural Factors
- Summary and Conclusions
- Author's Note
- References
- 3. The Illusion of Causality: A Cognitive Bias Underlying Pseudoscience
- The Adaptive Bias in Pattern Detection
- Correct Estimation of Causality
- Biased Estimation of Causality
- Factors That Produce the Causal Illusion
- An Example from Pseudo-medicine
- Simple Conditioning Models and Causal Illusions
- The Bright Side of Causal Illusions
- Conclusions
- Acknowledgments
- References
- 4. Hard Science, Soft Science, and Pseudoscience: Implications of Research on the Hierarchy of the Sciences
- Comte's Hierarchy of the Sciences
- Empirical Indicators of Hierarchical Placement
- Genuine versus Pseudoscience
- Pseudoscientific Beliefs within the Hierarchy
- Discussion
- References
- II. What Pseudoscience Costs Society
- 5. Food-o-science Pseudoscience: The Weapons and Tactics in the War on Crop Biotechnology
- Dinner, an Easy Target for Charlatans
- The Danger of Soft Sortascience
- Human Misery Spawns Agriculture
- Directed Human Intervention in Genetic Improvement
- The Food-o-scientist Toolbox
- Specific Examples of Food-o-science
- Conclusion
- References.
- 6. An Inside Look at Naturopathic Medicine: A Whistleblower's Deconstruction of Its Core Principles
- Introduction
- A Brief History of Naturopathic Theory
- Naturopathic Medicine Today and Its Six Principles
- First, Do No Harm
- The Healing Power of Nature
- Identify and Treat the Root Cause of Disease
- Doctor as Teacher
- Treat the Whole Person
- Prevention
- Conclusion
- Notes
- References
- 7. Risky Play and Growing Up: How to Understand the Overprotection of the Next Generation
- Introduction
- Play's Complexity-More Than Having Fun
- Benefits of Risky Play
- Evolutionary Function of Play and Risky Play
- Attempts to Regulate Play's Riskiness
- The Science of Risk Perception
- Normal Fear and Pathological Anxiety
- The Function of Fear: Avoidance and Safety Behaviors
- Phobias
- The Problem with Believing Worry Is Helpful: Parents Worry
- Generalized Anxiety Disorder: Exaggerated Worry
- The Knock-On Implications for Older Members of Society: The Infantilization of Our Young Adults and the Peculiar Case of Trigger Warnings
- Students Are Not More Vulnerable Than the General Population
- Universities Need Academic and Intellectual Freedom
- How to Treat Exaggerated Negative Emotional Reactions
- Not Learning to Cope Is to Not Mature Adequately
- How Too Much Safety and Protection Can Be Harmful
- Conclusions
- References
- 8. The Anti-Vaccine Movement: A Litany of Fallacy and Errors
- Naturalistic Fallacy: A View That What Is Natural Is Inherently Good and What Is Unnatural Inherently Bad
- Nirvana Fallacy (Perfect Solution Fallacy): The View That If a Solution Is Not Perfect, It Is Worthless
- Shifting the Burden of Proof (See Onus Probandi): "I Need Not Prove My Claim, You Must Prove It Is False."
- Anecdotal Fallacy: Using a Personal Experience or Examples to Extrapolate Without a Statistically Significant Number of Cases That Could Provide Scientifically Compelling Evidence
- False Authority (Single Authority): Using an Expert of Dubious Credentials
- Moving the Goalposts (Raising the Bar): After Evidence Is Presented in Response to a Specific Claim, Some Other (Often Greater) Evidence Is Demanded
- Genetic Fallacy: Where a Conclusion Is Based Solely on Something or Someone's Origin, With No Regard to Current Meaning or Context
- Appeal to Motive: Where a Premise Is Dismissed by Calling into Question the Motives of Its Proposer
- Cherry Picking: Pointing to Individual Cases or Data That Seem to Confirm a Particular Position, While Ignoring a Significant Portion of Related Cases or Data That May Contradict That Position
- Bad Science or Math
- Middle Ground: Saying That the Middle Point between Two Extremes Must Be the Truth
- Escape to the Future: Claiming That an Idea Will Soon Prevail Because the Emerging Evidence Is Just Around the Corner. "Science Was Wrong Before": Science Has Been Wrong in the Past, Therefore Science Cannot Be Trusted Now
- Finally, No Discussion of the Anti-Vaccine Movement Would Be Complete Without a Discussion of Conspiracy Theories and Deception
- Deception
- Conclusion
- Note
- References
- III. Scientific (or Pseudoscientific) Soundness
- 9. Understanding Pseudoscience Vulnerability through Epistemological Development, Critical Thinking, and Science Literacy
- Introduction
- Science Literacy
- Critical Thinking
- Epistemological Development
- Media Distortions of Science: The Spread of Pseudoscience
- The Mindfulness Movement
- The State of the Research
- Media Claims by High-Profile Mindfulness Figures
- Getting Beyond the Hype
- Where the Field Needs to Go.
- Addressing Pseudoscience Vulnerability
- References
- 10. Scientific Failure as a Public Good: Illustrating the Process of Science and Its Contrast with Pseudoscience
- Introduction
- The Structure of Scientific Failures
- The OPERA Experiment and Faster-Than-Light Neutrinos
- BICEP2 and Primordial Gravitational Waves
- Hydrino Physics and the Structure of Pseudoscience
- Conclusions
- Appendix A: The OPERA Experiment
- Appendix B: The BICEP2 Experiment
- Appendix C: "Hydrino" Physics
- Note
- References
- 11. Evidence-Based Practice as a Driver of Pseudoscience in Prevention Research
- Introduction
- The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration's National Registry
- A Systems Approach to Understanding Pseudoscience in Drug Prevention Research
- Discussion
- Notes
- References
- 12. Scientific Soundness and the Problem of Predatory Journals
- Introduction
- Setting the Scene
- Predatory Journals are Enabling the Publishing and Distribution of Much Pseudoscience
- Motivations for Authoring Pseudoscience and Submitting It to Scholarly Publications
- The Imprimatur of Science
- Payments from Authors and the Breakdown of Demarcation
- Pseudoscience at the Journal Level
- Information Resources Are Polluted by Research Published in Predatory Journals
- The Rise of Boundary Work
- Looking Ahead: Scholarly Publishing and the Dissemination of Pseudoscience
- References
- 13. Pseudoscience, Coming to a Peer-Reviewed Journal Near You
- References
- IV. Pseudoscience in the Mainstream
- 14. "Integrative" Medicine: Integrating Quackery with Science-Based Medicine
- Pseudoscience Insinuates Itself in Medical Academia and Medicine
- What Is "Integrative Medicine"?
- The Problem with Integrative Medicine
- The Blind Spot of Evidence-Based Medicine
- Integrative Medicine: Harms versus Questionable Benefits.
- "Integrating" Quackery: The Future of Medicine?
- References
- 15. Hypnosis: Science, Pseudoscience, and Nonsense
- Popular Media and Hypnosis
- Is Hypnosis a Trance State?
- Hypnotic Phenomena
- Hypnosis and Psychotherapy
- Conclusions
- References
- 16. Abuses and Misuses of Intelligence Tests: Facts and Misconceptions
- Can Intelligence Be Defined as a Singular Construct?
- The Definition of Intelligence
- Intelligence as a Quotient
- Is Intelligence a Fixed Construct?
- Broad Theories of Intelligence
- Pseudoscience
- Conclusions
- References
- 17. Reflections on Pseudoscience and Parapsychology: From Here to There and (Slightly) Back Again
- Introduction
- Early Years
- Epiphany
- Type I Skeptics
- Type II Skeptics
- Science, Nonscience, and Pseudoscience
- The Scientific Status of Parapsychology
- Conclusion
- Note
- References
- V. Science Activism: How People Think about Pseudoscience
- 18. Using Case Studies to Combat a Pseudoscience Culture
- First Things First: What Is Science?
- Who Are Scientists and Where Do We Find Them?
- The Canons of Science
- Commandments for the Scientist in the Lab and Field
- Commandments for the Scientist Interacting with Society
- How Scientists Can Go Wrong-"Methinks It Is Like a Weasel"
- Case Studies-A Rehearsal for Life
- Using Case Studies to Teach about Science
- Pseudoscience and How Do We Deal with It?
- What's the Harm of Pseudoscience?
- Can We Train People (Students) to Detect Pseudoscience?
- What Is a Teacher to Do?
- Is It Hopeless?
- Final Thoughts
- Acknowledgments
- References
- 19. "HIV Does Not Cause AIDS": A Journey into AIDS Denialism
- Discovering Denialism
- Just the Fake Facts
- Meet Joe Newton
- Entering the Dark Side
- A Network of Denialism
- It Gets Worse
- AIDS Denialism in the Courts
- Where We Stand
- References.