The Common Flaw Needless Complexity in the Courts and 50 Ways to Reduce It.
"The American lawsuit is riddled with needless complexity. This book proposes fifty changes-that decide cases promptly-more on the facts than the law-more for the parties than the lawyers-more for the consequences to the people and the public-and in words we can all understand"--
Clasificación: | Libro Electrónico |
---|---|
Autor principal: | |
Formato: | Electrónico eBook |
Idioma: | Inglés |
Publicado: |
Chicago :
Brandeis University Press,
2023.
|
Colección: | Brandeis Series in Law and Society Series.
|
Temas: | |
Acceso en línea: | Texto completo |
Tabla de Contenidos:
- Intro
- Contents
- Preface
- Acknowledgments
- 1. Prefer humanity to complexity
- 2. Rethink 90 percent of the typical complaint
- make it about key facts, not law
- 3. Address basic pleading and proof deficiencies with a single motion
- 4. Decide cases once
- use agency remands sparingly
- 5. Reconsider standing challenges
- they invite more lawsuits
- 6. Reduce fighting over subject matter jurisdiction
- the unheard will not remain unseen
- 7. Order discovery when a case begins
- police it without written motions
- 8. Creatively manage complex cases
- No case should be too big to try
- 9. Mediate, but don't delay the case for it
- 10. Streamline trials
- they'll be more final, more credible
- 11. Directly involve judges in jury selection
- 12. Increase juror numbers and diversity with remote jury trials
- 13. Question the number of motions in limine
- 14. Most exhibits prove undisputed facts
- we don't need them
- 15. Actively oppose cumulative and time-wasting testimony
- 16. Too much expert testimony is discrediting experts
- 17. Consider common sense first in family court
- 18. Introduce time clocks to encourage efficient trials
- 19. Needless objections annoy judges and jurors
- 20. Make a point, not a muddle, with prior testimony
- 21. Punish misconduct when it happens rather than in a separate proceeding
- 22. Cross-examine crisply, crushingly, or not at all
- 23. Humanize overstuffed, bewildering jury charges and interrogatories
- 24. Save time in court trials by substituting longer closing arguments for posttrial briefing
- 25. Keep cases in the hands of a single judge from start to finish
- 26. Speed cases to trial with judicial administration instead of slowing them down
- 27. Accelerate and simplify justice with technology
- 28. Virtual proceedings should be the rule
- 29. As a judge, prefer the model of a village elder
- 30. Cases are better resolved on their facts than on the law
- 31. Deploy canons of construction sparingly-only when they have a compelling reason to exist
- 32. Rarely resort to legislative history
- it's often unreliable
- 33. Reduce distractions by identifying fallacies
- 34. Don't blur laws to conquer facts
- 35. Endless consumer disclosures aren't doing us any good
- they are just low-hanging fruit
- 36. Reduce judicial testiness
- Use multipoint tests only when each point has meaning
- 37. Similar-sounding cases aren't precedent
- 38. The best legal writing is literature, not formula
- 39. Don't plod through the history of the case and familiar standards
- 40. Junk the jargon
- 41. Needless detail is...
- 42. The best appellate decisions deeply and plainly explain the law
- 43. There is a better home for law clerks outside of busy work and junior judging
- 44. Appellate courts should reform rusty rules
- 45. The best trial court decisions get straight to saying who wins and why