Ratio decidendi. : Guiding Principles of Judicial Decisions. Vol. 1: Case Law.

HauptbeschreibungAlthough the problem of ratio decidendi concerns the essence of law and justice, very little comparative work between the Continental and Anglo-American legal systems has been done on the topic. Legal literature often repeats that it is one of the sharpest points of contrast between...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Clasificación:Libro Electrónico
Autor principal: Bryson, W. Hamilton
Otros Autores: Dauchy, Serge
Formato: Electrónico eBook
Idioma:Inglés
Publicado: Berlin : Duncker & Humblot, 2013.
Colección:Comparative Studies in Continental and Anglo-American Legal History - 25/1.
Temas:
Judicial opinions.
Judgments.
Justice, Administration of.
Legal opinions.
Jugements.
LAW / Legal History
Acceso en línea:Texto completo
Tabla de Contenidos:
  • Laurens Winkel: Ratio Decidendi
  • Legal Reasoning in Roman Law; I. Introduction; II. Hierarchy of Legal Sources; III. Short History of Earlier Research; IV. Rationes Decidendi in Pre-Classical Roman Law; V. Ratio Decidendi in Classical Roman Law; VI. Some Remarks on Medieval Roman Law and Ratio Decidendi; VII. Conclusions; Jean Hilaire: Ratio decidendi au Parlement de Paris d'après les registres d'Olim (1254-1318); I. L'influence du cadre institutionnel sur le processus de décision; 1. La curia regis sous le règne de saint Louis; 2. La transition vers la cour de Parlement.
  • II. La nature des motifs de la décision1. La grâce et l'équité; 2. Le jugement en droit; Summary; Paul Brand: Reasoned Judgments in the English Medieval Common Law 1270 to 1307; I.; II.; III.; IV.; V.; Richard H. Helmholz: The Ratio Decidendi in England: Evidence from the Civilian Tradition; I. Introduction; II. Medieval Practice; III. Later Medieval Developments; IV. English Developments; V. Conclusion; Véronique Demars-Sion et Serge Dauchy: La non motivation des décisions judiciaires dans l'ancien droit français: un usage controversé; I. La lente affirmation de l'usage.
  • 1. Le silence des textes2. Les hésitations de la doctrine; II. Les nécessaires dérogations à l'usage; 1. Les exceptions à l'usage; 2. Le contournement de l'usage: l'oeuvre des arrêtistes; Summary; John Finlay: Ratio Decidendi in Scotland 1650 to 1800; The Theoretical Importance of Rationes; The Preservation and Presentation of Rationes; The Importance of Rationes in Legal Practice; Precedent and Natural Law; James Oldham: Lord Mansfield, Stare Decisis, and the Ratio Decidendi 1756 to 1788; Stare Decisis; Legislation; Secondary Authorities; Conclusion.
  • J. Thomas Wren: The Common Law of England in Virginia 1776 to 1830Charles F. Hobson: Precedent, Statute, and Law in John Marshall's Jurisprudence 1801 to 1835; I. Precedent; II. Statutory Construction; Jean-Louis Halpérin: The Court of Cassation in Nineteenth-Century France and the Binding Effect of Rationes Decidendi; Georges Martyn: The Judge and the Formal Sources of Law in the Low Countries (19th-20th Centuries): From 'Slave' to 'Master'?; I. The Legal Culture of the Low Countries in the Nineteenth Century: a French Heritage.
  • II. Scientific Research on Ratio Decidendi in the Low Countries: State of the ArtIII. The Judge's (Formal) Style; IV. The Use of the Formal Sources of Law; 1. The Netherlands; 2. Belgium; a) The Formal Sources of the Law in the Nineteenth Century; b) The Formal Sources of the Law Today; V. Evaluation by Way of Conclusion; Matthew C. Mirow: Case Law in Mexico 1861 to 1919: The Work of Ignacio Luis Vallarta; I. Jurisprudencia Today; II. Sources of Nineteenth-century Jurisprudencia; III. Jurisprudencia Criticized; IV. Vallarta and Jurisprudencia.

Ejemplares similares